2025 NFL Draft Scouting Report - Carl Smith Jr.
Defensive Back Scouting Report - Carl Smith Jr.
2025 NFL DRAFTWR SCOUTING REPORT
Carl Smith Jr.
Position: Wide Receiver - Slot
College: Robert Morris University
Height: 6' 0"
Weight: 178 lbs
Class: Graduate Student


Newt Westen


Carl Smith Jr. is a graduate student wide receiver who spent one year at Virginia Tech (RS), three years at Lafayette College, and his final year at Robert Morris University. He was a team captain for Lafayette in 2023, showcasing his commitment to his team, work ethic, and leadership. Despite suffering a groin injury that limited his availability during the 2023 season, Smith displayed promising attributes that could translate to the next level. He showed that he could play large at the catch point and attack the ball in the air as well as ideal, dependable hands. As he has progressed throughout his collegiate career, he has shown growth and improvement in his game, culminating with a final season more than doubling his production at Lafayette.
Strengths:
Length and Catch Radius: Solid frame for a 6'0" receiver and consistently extends his hands at the catch point, attacking the ball in the air.
Route Running: Shifty route runner with fluid movement and a developed route tree to create separation.
Catch Concentration: Exceptional focus in contested situations, showing the ability to haul in catches in traffic.
Weaknesses:
Low Production: His collegiate production has been underwhelming, limiting his ability to showcase consistency.
Level of Competition: Played against a lower level of competition, raising concerns about his ability to transition to higher levels.
Frame: A lighter build at 178 lbs; will need to add mass to compete with physical defenders.
Outlook:
Smith's combination of length, route-running ability, and concentration at the catch point makes him an intriguing prospect for teams seeking depth at receiver. His skill set projects best to the slot in the NFL, where he can use his shifty routes and quickness to create mismatches. While Smith does not project as a drafted player, he should earn an opportunity to try out with teams. His ability to run crisp routes and make tough catches will give him a chance to impress coaches and potentially carve out a role as a developmental player.
Grade: UDFA
Robert Morris wide receiver Carl Smith Jr. (0) lines up pre snap during his final season.